Tags
baking soda, Baking with Julia, beef brisket, boiled cabbage, boiled potatoes, corned beef, Dorie Greenspan, fennel seed, Ireland, Irish Soda Bread, Irish Tradition, leavener, potatoe famine, soda bread, tradition, Tuesdays with Dorie
It’s Tuesday with Dorie again, and this week we have made Irish Soda bread! In a couple of weeks, we will all be going to Ireland and Scotland for a week with some friends for a little mini vacation and so I have been looking into Irish Soda bread recipes quite a bit with the intention of making some so this came at just the right time for me.

The recipe in the book calls just for white unbleached bread flour while all the Irish recipes that I have found call for either all whole wheat flour or a combination of the two so I decided to go 50-50. It made just the perfect color in the overall loaf and I was very happy with the texture as well, and it was just so darned easy to make!



Since this assignment landed in the middle of our largest family visit in Idaho, my mother-in-law agreed to let me make a full traditional Irish meal to go with the bread and serve it on St. Patrick’s day. But we would be having as many family members that wanted to come over to eat, so we had to make quite a bit of everything to prepare for the flood of family that comes in a steady stream all day long. Awhile back, I had brined my own corned beef and it turned out really good (although with the wrong cut of meat) and due to the sheer number of people we would be expecting for this meal, my mother-in-law bought a ten pound beef brisket to cure. I was very excited to see how the cure would work out with the proper cut of meat and to toast the spices again since the last time, I smoked out our kitchen by toasting some of the spices ground and the rest whole. So this time I only toasted the spices that we had that were whole and left the ground ones to be separated and added to the brine water and the final boiling water… it turns out that boiling the ground spices smokes out the kitchen more intensely, causing anyone who lifts the lid to check on the beef to cough pretty deeply, so I would suggest going out and getting whole allspice (usually the most potent culprit) and any of the other necessary spices before using them in the brine.

We bought three heads of cabbage to boil, adding a tablespoon of fennel seeds to the water they boiled in and about five pounds of boiled baby red potatoes for our meal. With a side of salad, a stick of butter for the very warm bread that came out of the oven just an hour before everyone arrived, the meal was incredibly filling and there was plenty for everyone that made their way to our house for an early dinner.


The bread dough itself came together very quickly, and buttermilk is fairly difficult to find around my mother-in-law’s house, so we managed to get enough to make two recipes worth and used whole milk to triple the recipe. The loaves looked crumbly, rustic and smelled amazing! Everyone was quite pleased with the texture and taste of the fresh-baked loaves, as well as with the rest of the meal as it was a first for almost everyone. The only thing that could have made it more complete was a pint of Guinness with a large, bubbly, white head on it but we made do with some local brew and sodas for the pregnant, children and others that weren’t interested in alcohol.

These loaves also keep very well, although most of the leftovers (of which there was very little) disappeared bit by bit as our guests left …. I think I will be leaving the recipe when I leave. Our meal led to some interesting discussions with the younger children that were still in school about the potato famine, Angela’s Ashes, and haggis…

In addition to our meal, we were celebrating two birthdays, a rather belated one for Mei and a couple of weeks early for her cousin Mackenzie so we made mini chocolate and green-dyed white cupcakes with a variety of green and Easter jimmies to add a sweet note to the end of a rather successful meal!
If you would like to bake along with us, pick up a copy of “Baking with Julia” by Dorie Greenspan and you can enjoy all these delicious treats with us too! If you would like the recipe, head over to Cathy’s page on My Culinary Mission or Carla’s page on Chocolate Moosey!
Great post, Alice
I cured my own brisket this year & couldn’t believe how much better it was than what I was used to. I don’t think I’ll ever go back…
Your dinner & bread look great.
Thanks Cher! It was really easy,…although it takes a few days in your fridge but I get way more out of it than the portions that you could get at the store and often for cheaper.
I love idaho. We go to Sun Valley twice a year. Hope you had a great visit!
That’s nice! We are further north
We did enjoy our visit!
Great pictures!
wow! what an amazing feast. great family gathering!
Wow. You went all out! That is the perfect Irish meal!
I do like the color of your bread with the 50-50 mix of flour. I will have to try that next time.
Thanks! It was a great mix and the most traditional, so I don’t think I will try it any other way
Perfect meal for the green holiday. You made some great looking bread that I’ll bet was a hit with these foods.
Love that you went all the way and made a whole Irish Meal. The cupcakes look awesome too.
Thanks! They were made with a cake mix out of a box, but it was easier to do that considering the amount of food we made!!
Wow! Your family went all out for St. Patrick’s Day! You did a great job. I agree that this bread is better when there’s some whole wheat thrown in. It really brings the correct flavour out.
I think so too! …Otherwise it’s just another dense lean bread, which can be nice but not particularly Irish…
Exactly!
I am so impressed with your pics and that you made all that food! Way to go! I did 50/50 with my flour too, but I did not really care for my final product. Maybe my buttermilk was bad or something? Who knows. But yours, yours look beautiful!
Hmmm….maybe you overworked your dough? That can make bread taste funny or the texture to be “off” … try it again sometime?
We have a really nice Artisan bread stand in our local market that does a great Irish soda bread, along with many others, so if we just want to try something else or skip the baking part, we can still get an exceptional loaf!
Your version with half whole wheat flour sounds and looks wonderful. And oh, do those cupcakes look good too!
oh they were delicious! Thanks!
Your whole meal looks great! I love the color of your bread, the 50-50 mix sounds great.
OMG I didnt realize you were doing TWD too!! how great!
What a great family meal…thanks for sharing!! How awesome to be traveling to Ireland and Scotland!!!!
Thanks! We are excited about the trip, although we still dont know where we are going in those places quite yet…. LOL!
What a great family get together, it sounds like so much fun. Your loaves look delicious and so does everything else!
Thanks! We all ate til we were full and it went over real well!
what a feast! lokks great, and the loaves are beautiful…i will try the 50/50 whole wheat next time myself.
The 50/50 mix is great! It was awesome!